UUM_Accn1200.xml Inventory of the Zuni land claims cases records Zuni land claims cases records Finding aid created by Gregory Smoak. J. Willard Marriott Library Special Collections

1993 (last modified: 2020)
295 South 1500 East Salt Lake City, Utah 84112 Business Number: 801-581-8863 special@library.utah.edu https://lib.utah.edu/collections/special-collections/index.php
This finding aid was produced using ArchivesSpace on 2026-04-09. Finding aid written in English. Finding aid based on DACS (Describing Archives: A Content Standard), 2nd Edition. J. Willard Marriott Library Special Collections Zuni land claims cases records Boyden, Stephen G. ACCN 1200 79 linear feet 150 boxes and 69 microfilm reels 1941-1991 The Zuni land claims cases records (1941-1991) consist of legal files concerning two suits brought by the New Mexico Zuni tribe against the U.S. government over land rights in New Mexico and Arizona, and a third suit over access to an important sacred site in eastern Arizona. Included are briefs, reports, trial transcripts, exhibits, appraisals, maps, and orders and opinions of the court. English

The records of the Zuni land claims cases begin in the mid-1970s with the tribe's efforts to regain the Zuni Salt Lake, a site of religious and economic importance located approximately forty miles south of the Zuni Reservation. In conjunction, the tribe sought to recover compensation on other claims. Between 1975 and 1978 several draft bills were debated and both houses of congress held hearings on the Zuni claims. On 15 May 1978, President Jimmy Carter signed Public Law 95-280, returning the Zuni Salt Lake to the tribe, and clearing the way for the tribe to file suit against the federal government in the United States Court of Claims.

With the passage of this act, the Zuni tribe brought Zuni I in 1979, in an effort to gain recognition of and compensation for aboriginal land rights in New Mexico and Arizona. The case went to trial in Salt Lake City, Utah, in March 1982, and the trial judge's opinion came on 27 May 1987. Judge Judith Ann Yannello found that the Zuni tribe "had aboriginal title to the land contained in the area claimed by the plaintiff . . . [that] this title existed from time immemorial . . . [and] The Zuni, exclusively, used and occupied this claim area." In a second opinion, Judge Yannello found that the United States "has failed to pay or award any compensation for the Zuni lands taken by the United States." After settlement negotiations and a land appraisal, final judgement in favor of the Zuni Tribe in the amount of $25,000,000 was entered on 22 January 1991. As of the summer of 1991, however, Congress had yet to appropriate the funds for the award. Two years after initiated Zuni I, the tribe filed docket 327-81L, a suit to recover compensation for Zuni trust lands. This case never went to trial, and was settled by an act of congress.

The third and final case, the United States of America v. Platt, involved access to an important Zuni shrine located in eastern Arizona. The Zunis' quadrennial pilgrimage to this site had been blocked by a land owner who refused to allow the Zunis to cross his land. In 1991, the courts decided in favor of the Zunis in this case.

Twenty-four hour advanced notice encouraged. Materials must be used on-site. Access to parts of this collection may be restricted under provisions of state or federal law.

Access to some material in this collection may be limited to particular Tribal Nation(s), family members associated with the material or recordings, or individuals with documented permission from the relevant Tribal Nation. These restrictions honor Indigenous cultural protocols, community authority, and the rights of those represented in the collection. For more information, consult the Special Collections statement regarding access to Indigenous materials.

The library does not claim to control copyright for all materials in the collection. An individual depicted in a reproduction has privacy rights as outlined in Title 45 CFR, part 46 (Protection of Human Subjects). For further information, please review the J. Willard Marriott Library's Use Agreement and Reproduction Request forms.

Gift of Stephen G. Boyden, attorney for the Zuni tribe, in 1991.

Collection Name, Collection Number, Box Number, Folder Number. Special Collections, J. Willard Marriott Library, The University of Utah.

Processed by Gregory Smoak in 1993.

Addendum processed by Valerie Richey in 1998.

Click here to read a statement on harmful language in library records.

The Zuni land claims cases records (1941-1991) include records from three separate cases. The Zuni Tribe of New Mexico v. the United States of America, Docket 161-79L [hereafter referred to as Zuni I], The Zuni Tribe of New Mexico v. the United States of America, Docket 327-84L [Zuni II], and The United States of America v. Platt [Zuni III]. Stephen G. Boyden served as the attorney for the Zuni tribe in all cases.

The records of Zuni I are arranged into nine parts. The first seven parts include the records of the case itself. Part eight contains the records of the land appraisal commissioned by the Zuni Tribe during the settlement process, and the final section consists of miscellaneous maps.

Part one contains the original court documents from 1979 to 1991 in four boxes. The documents include motions, petitions, responses, briefs, findings of facts, and reports filed by the plaintiff and the defendant, as well as the trial judges' orders and opinions. The documents are arranged in chronological order based on the date they were filed with the United States Court of Claims.

Part two consists of transcripts of the trial held in Salt Lake City between 15 March and 25 March 1982. Included is the testimony and cross-examination of Zuni lay witnesses, and expert witnesses for both the plaintiff and defendant. This section includes nine volumes of transcripts and three volumes of page corrections in two boxes.

The exhibits of the plaintiff [the Zuni Tribe] are found in Part three. The plaintiff's exhibit list [box 7, book 1] describes each exhibit. Plaintiff's exhibits [PX] 0001 - 0274 include primary and secondary sources, photographs, maps and depositions. Beginning with PX 1000, the plaintiff's exhibits consist of expert witness reports and their supporting documentation. For instance, T. J. Ferguson's "Zuni Settlement and Land Use: An Archaeological Perspective" is numbered PX 1000, and his supporting documentation consists of PX 1001 - 1310. The same pattern continues for the expert reports of Fred Eggan [PX 2000], Triloki N. Pandey [PX 3000], Ward Allan Minge [PX 4000], S. Lyman Tyler [PX 5000], Myra Ellen Jenkins [PX 6000], and E. Richard Hart [PX 7000]. For the most part, the supporting documentation for each report consists of title pages and/or excerpts of the sources cited. The sole exception is the PX 8000 series of exhibits dealing with Zuni archaeology and pottery which is independent of an expert report. The plaintiff's exhibits are contained in twenty-three boxes.

Part four consists of the defendant's [the United States] exhibits [DX]. The defendant's exhibit list [box 31, folder 1] describes each exhibit. Included are reports by the defendant's two expert witnesses; Earl H. Elam [DX 149 and 150], and Donald E. Worcester [DX 200]. The defendant's exhibits are contained in two boxes.

Part five consists of various exhibits lists contained in two boxes. The lists index the plaintiff's and defendant's exhibits several ways, including exhibit number, title and author.

Part six includes rough drafts of the plaintiff's findings of fact to be submitted to the court. Included is the original draft, and revisions by S. Lyman Tyler, Fred Eggan and Ward Allan Minge.

Part seven contains miscellaneous papers and correspondence including staff documents, miscellaneous legal documents, and draft exhibits lists.

Part eight contains the appraisal report prepared by Flavell, Tennenbaum & Associates of North Hollywood, California in January 1991. The supporting documentation is arranged according to subject. Thus, "F" documents relate to farming and ranching, "I" to irrigation and water rights, "T" to timber resources and so on. For the most part, these exhibits contain excerpts from various primary and secondary sources, but in some cases contain the entire work. The final portion of this section contains seventeen appraisals prepared by others which include portions of or all of the Zuni claim area. These appraisal records are contained in twenty-one boxes. Finally, part eight contains to appraisal report prepared by Market Data Research.

Finally, part nine contains one large map folder of miscellaneous maps used in the preparation of the case, but which were never entered into evidence. Stored along with the map folders are 14 oversize wall-hanging maps used in the trial. Each is rolled and stored separately.

The records of Zuni II are boxed in two parts, following the pattern set for Zuni I. The first part includes the plaintiff's exhibits. Again, these include the expert witness reports and supporting documentation. Part two, arranged in the same manner, includes the defendant's exhibits.

The Library currently holds only one box of materials from Zuni III, the religious access case. These consist of expert witness reports by E. Richard Hart.

The addendum to the collection contains records, research, correspondence, and other documents regarding the Zuni land claims. Research, correspondence, contracts, an exhibit list, appraisal reports, and other documents pertaining to Zuni I are contained in boxes 114-119. Depositions regarding Zuni II are housed in boxes 120-127. Information and copies of the laws and order codes for the Zuni people are in boxes 128-129. Legal research, correspondence, financial records, memoranda, court documents and other information regarding the case, Zuni Water, are housed in boxes 130-132. Tribal petitions regarding the case, Zuni Heaven, are contained in boxes 133-134. Documents pertaining to several other lawsuits that the Zuni people filed are in boxes 135-137 and are titled the Zuni Claims. Stephen Boyden was the lawyer for the Zuni people, and the research that he did for these different cases are housed in boxes 138-149. Documents regarding the White River Shale Project are contained in box 138. The Zuni tribal code is in box 139. Zuni codes, memos, and other documents are housed in box 140. Financial records are contained in boxes 141-143. Copies of the Zuni's laws are in box 144. Additional research, correspondence, client records, and other material regarding these cases are in boxes 145-149.

Audio-visual materials were transferred to the Multimedia Division of Special Collections (A0515). Oversize maps, surveys, and other materials are housed in the Manuscripts Division's map case.

 Indians of North America--Legal status, laws, etc. Zuni Indians--Land tenure Zuni Indians--Claims Zuni Indians--Government relations Civil Rights Legal files Reports Maps (documents) Appraisals (financial records) Records Regarding the Zuni Salt Lake and the Passage of Public Law 95-280 I Correspondence and Records Regarding the Zuni Salt Lake and Other Claims 1941-1980 Correspondence and Documents Regarding the Zuni Salt Lake 1965-1983 1 1-2 Zuni Salt Lake, Leases and Contracts 1941-1975 1 3 Technical and Geological Reports Regarding the Zuni Salt Lake 1965-1970 1 4 Zuni Salt Lake, Property Inventories 1 5 E. Richard Hart, "A Preliminary Review of Documentary Evidence Relating to the Zuni Salt Lake" 1 6 Map of the Zuni Salt Lake 1 7 Internal Correspondence and Memos 1973-1978 1 8 Bureau of Indian Affairs, Correspondence and Documents 1951-1978 1 9 Bureau of Land Management, Correspondence 1975-1976 1 10 Intertribal Organizations, Correspondence and Resolutions 1975-1976 1 11 State of New Mexico, Correspondence 1975-1977 1 12 Zuni Tribe of New Mexico, Correspondence 1973-1977 1 13 Correspondence Regarding Zuni Resources 1977-1978 1 14 Zuni General Council 1978 1 15 Passamaquoddy Claims Documents 1971-1972 1 16 Claims Settlement Proposals, Goshute Example 1 17 Miscellaneous Claims Documents 1 18 Zuni Claims Cases, Miscellaneous Notes 1 19 Miscellaneous Materials Regarding the Zuni Reservation 1 20 Miscellaneous Correspondence 1975-1980 1 21 Billings and Receipts 1973-1980 1 22 Records Relating to the Passage of Public Law 95-280 Correspondence and records Regarding the Indian Claims Commission 1966-1980 2 1 U. S. House of Representatives, Correspondence 1975-1978 2 2 U. S. House of Representatives, Documents 1976-1977 2 3 U. S. Senate, Correspondence 1974-1977 2 4 U. S. Senate, Documents 1975-1976 2 5 Statements Regarding Zuni Legislation: Zuni Witnesses 2 6 Statements Regarding Zuni Legislation: Senate Hearings 1975 2 7 Statements Regarding Zuni Legislation: House Hearings 1976 2 8 Transcript of House Hearings On Zuni Land Claims 1976 2 9 Statements Regarding Zuni Legislation: House Hearings 1977 2 10 Draft Legislation, Zuni Land Claims 2 11 Senate Bill 877 1975 2 12 House Bill 4212 1975 2 13 Senate Bill 482 1977 2 14 House Bill 3787 1977 2 15 House Bill 2664 1977 2 16 Public Law 95-280 1978 2 17

"An act to direct the Secretary of the Interior to purchase and hold certain lands in trust for the Zuni Indian Tribe of New Mexico, and to confer jurisdiction on the Court of Claims with respect to land claims of such tribe."

 The Zuni Tribe of New Mexico v. the United States of America, Docket 161-79L II

Court Documents 1979-1991

 Court Documents Court Documents 1979 3 1

Petition, 27 April 1979.

Reference to Trial Judge, 15 May 1979.

Motion for Leave to File Answer Out of Time, 2 July 1979.

Answer to Plaintiff's Petition, 5 July 1979.

Memorandum of Pretrial Conference, 7 September 1979.

Joint Motion for Amendment of Memorandum of Pretrial Conference Filed September 7, 1979; 7 November 1979.

Trial Judge's Order Re: Joint Motion for Amendment, 20 November 1979.

 Court Documents 1980 3 2

Motion for Leave to File First Amended Petition, 27 May 1980.

First Amended Petition, 9 June 1980.

Motion for Leave to File First Amended Answer, 12 August 1980.

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Order Extending Deadline to File Experts' Preliminary Reports, 18 August 1980.

Defendant's First Amended Answer, 10 September 1980.

Defendant's Motion for Enlargement of Time to Exchange Expert Reports and for Modification of the Calendar of Events, 20 October 1980.

 Court Documents 1981 3 3

Motion for Order Setting Date and Place of Trial, 9 February 1981.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Order Setting Date and Place of Trial, 18 February 1981.

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's Response, 3 March 1981.

Defendant's Motion for an Order Compelling Plaintiff to Answer Defendant's Interrogatories, 16 March 1981.

G. Richard Hill to Judge Judith Yannello, 18 March 1981.

Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for an Order Compelling . . ., 25 March 1981.

Defendant's Reply to Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion . . ., 31 March 1981.

Plaintiff's Motion for an Order Excluding Dr. Worcester's Written Report and Prohibiting Dr. Worcester from Testifying at Trial . . ., 2 April 1981.

Trial Judge's Order Re: Defendant's Motion for an Order Compelling . . ., 2 April 1981.

Trial Judges Order Setting Trial, 3 April 1981.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion for an Order Excluding Dr. Worcester . . ., 9 April 1981.

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's Response Opposing Plaintiff's Motion . . . Excluding Dr. Worcester . . ., 20 April 1981.

Trial Judge's Supplemental Order Setting Trial, 22 April 1981.

 Court Documents 1981 3 4

Trial Judges Order Re: Plaintiff's Motion to Strike [Dr. Worcester's Report and testimony], 6 May 1981.

Defendant's Motion for Modification of the Schedule of Pretrial Events, 13 May 1981.

Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Specific Portions of Dr. Worcester's Report . . ., 1 June 1981.

Defendant's Motion for Enlargement of Time in which to File Its Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Strike, 4 June 1981.

Plaintiff's Motion for a Pre-Trial Order Regarding "Exclusive Use," 10 June 1981.

Trial Judge's Order Re: Plaintiff's Motion Filed June 10, 1981, 12 June 1981.

[Plaintiff's] Petition for Review, 26 June 1981

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Strike, 30 June 1981.

 Court Documents 1981 3 5

Defendant's Motion for Enlargement of Time in which to File Its Response to Plaintiff's Petition for Review, 6 July 1981.

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's Response Opposing Plaintiff's Motion to Strike, 15 July 1981.

Trial Judges Order Re: Plaintiff's Motion of June 1, 1981 to Strike, 24 July 1981.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Petition for Review, 27 July 1981.

Trial Judge's Order Re: Pretrial and Trial Proceedings, 31 July 1981.

Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for Reconsideration Pursuant to Order of July, 24 1981, 11 August 1981.

Interlocutory Review of Denial of Pretrial Motion, 14 August 1981.

Motion for Restatement of Trial Schedule, 21 August 1981.

Defendant's Reply to Plaintiff's Response Regarding Dr. Worcester's Report, 21 August 1981.

Motion to Set Dates for Further Proceedings, 24 August 1981.

Trial Judge's Order Re: Report of Defendant's Expert and Further Pretrial Proceedings, 25 August 1981.

 Court Documents 1981 3 6

Report Re: Pretrial and Trial Schedule, 2 September 1981.

Order, 18 September 1981.

Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Portions of Defendant's Expert Witnesses Reports, 20 November 1981.

[Defendant's] Motion for Enlargement of Time, 30 November 1981.

Objections to Defendant's Motion for Enlargement of Time, 4 December 1981.

Trial Judge's Memorandum Re: Pretrial Conference and Order RE: Further Proceedings, 14 December 1981.

Order, 14 December 1981.

Trial Judge's Order Re: Scheduling of Case for Trial, 22 December, 1981.

 Court Documents 1982 3 7

Trial Judge's Order Setting Case for Trial, 20 January 1982.

[Trial Judge's] Order Closing Proof and Concerning the Times for Filing Requested Findings of Fact and Briefs, 17 May 1982.

Order, 28 May 1982.

Plaintiff's Motion for Extension of Time to File Requested Findings of Fact and Brief, 23 August 1982.

 Court Documents 1982 3 8

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Second Extension of Time to File Requested Findings of Fact and Brief, 4 November 1982.

[Plaintiff's] Motion for an Order requiring Reporter to Correct Transcript, 4 November 1982.

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Leave to File Response Out of Time, 26 November 1982.

 Court Documents 1982 3 9

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's Response to Motion for an Order Requiring Reporter to Correct Transcript, 1 December 1982.

Frank T. Peartree, Clerk of Court to Ira Sharp, Alderson Reporting Company, 22 December 1982.

Order Re: Plaintiff's Motion to Correct Transcript of Trial Proceedings, 22 December 1982.

 Court Documents 1983 3 10

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Leave to Exceed Page Limitation on Brief, 6 January 1983.

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Final Extension of Time to File Requested Findings of Fact and Brief, 13 January 1983.

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Extension of Time to File Footnotes to Plaintiff's Requested Findings of Fact, 1 February 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 3 11

Plaintiff's Post-Trial Brief, 102 pages, 1 February 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 3 12

Plaintiff's Requested Findings of Fact, 105 pages, 15 maps, 1 February 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 3 13

Footnotes to Plaintiff's Requested Findings of Fact, 99 pages, 18 February 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 3 14

Statement of Alderson Reporting [Rose Ann Sharp, Alderson Reporting, to Frank Peartree, Clerk of Court], 22 February 1983.

Order Re: Correction of Transcript, 23 February 1983.

[Plaintiff's] Second Motion for Correction of Transcript, 7 March 1983.

Defendant's Response to Court's Order RE: Correction of Transcript, 8 March 1983.

Order Re: Plaintiff's Motion to Correct Transcript, 18 March 1983.

[Defendant's] Motion for Reconsideration of the Court's Order with Reference to Plaintiff's Motion to Correct Transcript, 28 March 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 4 1

Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for Reconsideration of the Court's Order . . ., 5 April 1983.

Corrected Transcript Pages Pursuant to Order of March 18, 1983, 12 April 1983.

Order Re: Corrections to Transcripts on Defendant's Motion for Reconsideration, 29 April 1983.

[Joint] Stipulation of Transcript Corrections, 26 May 1983.

[Plaintiff's] Memorandum in Support of Requested Corrections Submitted Pursuant to Order of April 29, 1983, 14 June 1983.

Interim Order Re: Transcript, 15 June 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 4 2

Order Re: Transcript Correction, 21 June 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 4 3

[Plaintiff's] Response to Interim Order . . ., 1 July 1983.

[Plaintiff's] Response to Order Re: Transcript Correction of June 21, 1983, 1 July 1983.

Defendant's response to Plaintiff's Memorandum . . . of April 29, 1983, 8 July 1983.

Order Re: Transcript Correction, 8 July 1983.

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Memorandum . . . of April 29, 1983, 25 July 1983.

[Plaintiff's] Response to Order Re: Transcript Correction of July 8, 1983, 25 July 1983.

[Defendant's] Motion for Enlargement of Time Within Which to File Findings of Fact and Brief, 28 July 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 4 4

[Plaintiff's] Response to Defendant's Motion for Enlargement of Time Within Which to File Findings of Fact and Brief, 8 August 1983.

Order Re: Correction of Transcript, 9 August 1983.

Order Re: Correction of Transcript, 11 August 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 4 5

Defendant's Requested Findings of Fact, Volume 1 of 3, 12 December 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 4 6

Defendant's Objections to Plaintiff's Requested Findings of Fact, Volume 2 of 3, 12 December 1983.

 Court Documents 1983 4 7

Defendant's Brief, Volume 3 of 3, 12 December 1983.

 Court Documents 1984 5 1

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Enlargement of Time, 5 March 1984.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Enlargement of Time, 15 March 1984.

 Court Documents 1984 5 2

Plaintiff's Reply Brief, Volume 1 of 3, 18 April 1984.

 Court Documents 1984 5 3

Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Objections to Requested Findings of Fact, Volume 2 of 3, 26 April 1984.

 Court Documents 1984 5 4

Plaintiff's Objections to Defendant's Requested Findings of Fact, Volume 3 of 3, 26 April 1984.

 Court Documents 1985 5 5

Entry of Appearance, 13 November 1985.

 Court Documents 1986 5 6

Notice of Change of Telephone Number, 14 January 1986.

Notice of Change of Telephone Number, 2 July 1986.

 Court Documents 1987 5 7

Opinion: Indian Claims; Extent of Aboriginal Land and Title; Exclusive Use and Occupancy, 27 May 1987.

Opinion: Indian Claims; Events and Dates of Taking of Aboriginal Land, 27 May 1987.

 Court Documents 1987 5 8

Plaintiff's Motion to Alter or Amend Decision of May 27, 1987, 8 June 1987.

Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Alter or Amend Decision of May 27, 1987, 22 June 1987.

Plaintiff's Notice of Related Cases, 23 June 1987.

Order [Assigning Judge John Napier], 24 June 1987.

Plaintiff's Motion for Leave to File Memorandum Out of Time, 17 July 1987.

Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Alter or Amend the Decision of May 27, 1987, 21 July 1987.

Motion for Leave to File Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Reply Regarding Amendment of the Decision of May 27, 1987, 24 July 1987.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Reply Regarding Amendment of the Decision of May 27, 1987, 27 July 1987.

Entry of Appearance, 19 August 1987.

Order requiring Supplemental Briefing, 28 September 1987.

Plaintiff's response to the Order Requiring Supplemental Briefing, 14 October, 1987.

Defendant's Motion for an Enlargement of Time, 2 November 1987.

Plaintiff's Response to Cases Furnished to Counsel by the Court, 3 November 1987.

Defendant's Second Motion for an Enlargement of Time, 9 November 1987.

Defendant's Supplemental Brief Pursuant to the Court's Order of September 28, 1987, 16 November 1987.

Notice of Change of Address for Attorney of Record for the Defendant, 18 November 1987.

 Court Documents 1988 5 9

Transcript of Proceedings of May 6, 1988, 13 May 1988.

Joint Motion to Set Dates for Further Proceedings, 25 May 1988.

Order Setting Dates for Further Proceedings, 26 May 1988.

Defendant's Motion for Enlargement of Time, 30 June 1988.

 Court Documents 1988 5 10

Defendant's Motion for Second Enlargement of Time, 1 August 1988.

Defendant's Motion for New Trial on Liability, 8 August 1988.

Notice of Correction of New Addresses for Attorney of Record for Defendant, 9 August 1988.

 Court Documents 1988 5 11

Plaintiff's Motion for Enlargement of Time, 21 September 1988.

Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for a New Trial on Liability, 31 October 1988.

Defendant's Motion for Enlargement of Time, 2 November 1988.

Defendant's Reply to Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for a New Trial on Liability, 2 December 1988.

Transcript of Proceedings of December 19, 1988, 27 December 1988.

 Court Documents 1989 6 1

Defendant's Status Report, 31 January 1989.

Plaintiff's Report to Court regarding Settlement Negotiation and Request for Pretrial Conference, 7 February 1989.

[Plaintiff's] Motion to Set Dates of Further Proceedings, 23 February 1989.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Set Dates for Further Proceedings, 7 March 1989.

[Plaintiff's] Motion for Ruling on the Issue of Recognized Title and for an Amended Schedule for Further Proceedings, 7 March 1989.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motions for Ruling . . ., 23 March 1989.

Transcript of Proceedings of 24 February 1989, 28 March 1989.

 Court Documents 1989 6 2

Order Re: Motion to Alter Decision of Predecessor Judge . . ., 19 April 1989.

Order Re: Status Reports, 4 May 1989.

Defendant's Status Report, 28 June 1989.

Order Re: Status Reports, 29 June 1989.

[Defendant's] Notice of Change of Address and Telephone Number, 31 August 1989.

Motion for Leave to File Out of Time Joint Report to the Court regarding Settlement Negotiations, 24 October 1989.

Plaintiff's Motion to Assign the Evaluation Phase of Case for Trial and to Set Dates for Further Proceedings, 22 December 1989.

 Court Documents 1990 6 3

Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Assign Valuation Phase of Case for Trial . . ., 8 January 1990.

Joint Report to the Court Regarding Settlement Negotiations, 9 January 1990.

Order, 8 February 1990.

Order, 15 February 1990.

Defendant's Memorandum Concerning Alternative Dispute Resolution and Proposed Trial Schedule, 21 February 1990.

Plaintiff's Memorandum Regarding Proposed Alternative Dispute Resolution and Suggested Dates for Further Proceedings, 21 February 1990.

Notice of Reassignment to Chief Judge Loren A. Smith, 26 February 1990.

Order, 27 February 1990.

Order, 2 April 1990.

Plaintiff's Motion to Reschedule Dates for Further Proceedings, 1 May 1990.

[Defendant's] Notice of Change of Name in Address, 2 May 1990.

Notice of Reassignment to Judge Robert H. Hodges, Jr., 3 May 1990.

Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Reschedule Dates for Further Proceedings, 4 May 1990.

 Court Documents 1991 6 4

Stipulation for Compromise Settlement and Entry of Final Judgement, 18 January 1991.

Stephen G. Boyden to Frank Peartree, Clerk of Court, January 18, 1991, 22 January 1991.

Judgement, 22 January 1991.

 Trial Transcripts, Volume I-IX and Superseded Pages Volume 1 1982 7 1

Opening statements and Zuni lay witnesses.

 Volume II 1982 7 2

Expert testimony of T. J. Ferguson and cross-examination.

 Volume III 1982 7 3

Expert testimony of Fred Eggan and Triloki N. Pandey, and cross-examination.

 Volume IV 1982 7 4

Expert testimony and cross-examination of Allan Ward Minge and S. Lyman Tyler.

 Volume V 1982 7 5

Expert testimony and cross-examination of Myra Ellen Jenkins and John Baxter.

 Volume VI 1982 7 6

Expert testimony and cross-examination of E. Richard Hart.

 Volume VII 1982 7 7

Expert testimony and cross-examination of Earl H. Elam.

 Volume VIII 1982 7 8

Expert testimony and cross-examination of Earl H. Elam and Donald E. Worcester.

 Volume IX 1982 8 1

Expert testimony and cross-examination of Donald E. Worcester.

 Uncorrected Pages Which Have Been Superseded, Vols. I-IX 8 2-3 Corrected Pages Which Have Been Superseded, Books 1-2 8 4 Plaintiff's Exhibit List and Exhibits

The plaintiff's exhibit list [Court's Exhibit 1, Volume 1] lists the author and gives a brief description of exhibits 0001-7968.

 Plaintiff's Exhibit [PX] List 9 1 PX001-0110 9 1-7 PX 0111-0136 10 1-2 PX 0137-053-Photographs 10 3-7 PX 0240-053 10 8

Photographic copies of PX 0248-0253 are also included. Large wall-hanging originals of Plaintiff's exhibits 0240-0253 are stored separately

 PX 025-"Rebuttal Reports of Plaintiff Zuni Indian Tribe," Volumes 1-2 10 9-10 PX 025-Deposition of Earl Elam 10 11 PX 025-Deposition of Donald Worcester 11 1 PX 025-Deposition of Alonzo Hustido 11 2 PX 0259-Deposition of Chester Mahooty 11 3 PX 0260-Deposition of Theodore Edaakie 11 4 PX 026-Deposition of Tom Awelagte 11 5 PX 026-Deposition of Frank Vacit 11 6 PX 026-Deposition of Seff Arachio 11 7 PX 026-Deposition of Alvin Lynn Nastacio 11 8 PX 026-Deposition of Ralph Quam 11 9 PX 026-Deposition of Fred Bowannie, Sr 11 10 PX 026-Deposition of Chester H. Gaspar 11 11 PX 026-Deposition of Mecalito Wyatsalucy 11 12 PX 026-Deposition of Oscar Nastacio 11 13 PX 0270-0274 11 14 Report of T. J. Ferguson and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 1000-1072 PX 1000. T. J. Ferguson, "Zuni Settlement and Land Use: An Archaeological Perspective" 12 1 PX 1001-1072 12 2-10 Supporting Documentation for Ferguson, "Zuni Settlement and Land Use." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1073-1149 13 Supporting Documentation for Ferguson, "Zuni Settlement and Land Use." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1150-1234 14 Supporting Documentation for Ferguson, "Zuni Settlement and Land Use." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1235-1310 15 Report of Fred Eggan and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 2000-2095 PX 2000. Fred Eggan, "Aboriginal Land Use of the Zuni Tribe" 16 1 PX 2001-2095 16 2-8 Report of Triloki N. Pandey and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 3000-3124 17 PX 3000. Triloki N. Pandey, "Some Reflections on Aboriginal Land Use of the Zuni Tribe" 17 1 PX 3001.01-3124 17 2-10 Report of Ward Allan Minge and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 4000-4037.02 18 PX 4000, Ward Allan Minge, "Zuni in Spanish and Mexican History" 18 1 PX 4001-4037.2 18 2-8 Supporting Documentation for Minge, "Zuni in Spanish and Mexican History." Plaintiff's Exhibits 4038-4107 19 Report of S. Lyman Tyler and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 5000-5053 20 PX 5000. S. Lyman Tyler, "The Zuni Indians Under the Laws of Spain, Mexico and the United States" 20 1 PX 5001-5053 20 2-7 Report of Myra Ellen Jenkins and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 6000-6169 21 PX 6000. Myra Ellen Jenkins, "The Pueblo of Zuni and United States Administration" 1846-1870 21 1 PX 6001.01-6169 21 2-12 Supporting Documentation for Jenkins, "The Pueblo of Zuni and United States Administration." Plaintiff's Exhibits 6170-6253 22 Report of E. Richard Hart and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 7000-7085 23 PX 7000. E. Richard Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land: With Emphasis on Details Relating to Incidents Occurring" Volume 1 1846-1946 23 1 PX 7000. E. Richard Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land . . .," Volume 2 23 2

Tables, maps and notes for Volume 1.

 PX 7001.01-7085 23 3-9 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land" Plaintiff's Exhibits 7087-7150 24 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land" Plaintiff's Exhibits 7151-7299 25 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land" Plaintiff's Exhibits 7300.01-7428 26 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land" Plaintiff's Exhibits 7429-7600 27 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land" Plaintiff's Exhibits 7601-7764 28 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land" Plaintiff's Exhibits 7765.01-7968 29 Archaeological Exhibits. Plaintiff's Exhibits 8000-8030. Exhibits 8025.01-8025.54 30 PX 8000-8012 30 1

PX 8000. Susan M. Collins, Director of the Zuni Archaeology Program to "Whom it May Concern," 4 March 1982.

PX 8001-8012. Photographs of Various Pottery Sherds Described in PX 8000.

 PX 8013-8024 30 2

Photographs of Various Pottery Sherds Described in PX 8000

 PX 8026-8027 30 3

"Occasional papers of the American West Center, University of Utah." 1 page list of titles.

Pueblo Indian III (New York: Garland Publishing Inc., 1974)

 PX 8028-8030 30 4 PX 8025.01-8025.54, Marked Topographic Maps 31 Defendant's Exhibit list [Court's Exhibit 1, Volume 2.] and Defendant's Exhibits 1-149 32

Exhibits 1-148 are supporting documentation to the reports of Earl H. Elam, DX 149 and 150.

 Defendant's exhibit list, Court's Exhibit 1, Volume 2. 32 1 DX 1-148 32 2-16 DX 149. Earl H. Elam, "A History of Zuni Land Utilization in Arizona and New Mexico, 1539 to Present" 1980 32 17 Defendant's Exhibits 150-221 33

Exhibits 151-173 are supporting documentation for the supplemental report of Earl H. Elam.

 DX 150. Earl H. Elam, "Supplemental Report" 1981 33 1 DX 151-173 33 2-3 DX 200. Donald E. Worcester, "Defendant's Rebuttal to the Zuni Indian Tribe of New Mexico v. the United States of America (Docket No. 161-79L)" 1981 33 4 DX 201.00-201.20. Supporting documentation for Worcester, "Defendant's Rebuttal . . ." 33 5 DX 202-221 33 6-13 Exhibit Lists 34 "Record List," 41 pages 1981 34 1 Draft of Defense Exhibit List, 19 pages 1982 34 2 "Subject List," 2 pages, and "Areas," 5 pages 1982 34 3 "By Exhibit #," 151 pages 1982 34 4 Errors and Miscellaneous Pages, 7 pages 1982 34 5 "Exhibit List," 62 pages 1982 34 6 "Exhibit List 1," pages 1-121 1982 34 7 "Exhibit List 1," pages 122-242 1982 34 8 "Pl's Index by Title," 122 pages 1982 34 9 "All Exhibits by Subject," 145 pages 1982 34 10 Exhibit Lists 35 "Pl's Abstracts by Exhibit #" 1982 35 1-3 "Def's Exhibits From-To" 1982 35 4 "Before 1846 & After" 1982 35 5 "Def's Exhibits by Author" 1982 35 6-7 Rough Drafts 36 "Draft #1 6/26/81," 46 pages 36 1 "Tyler" [Revised by S. Lyman Tyler] 36 2 "Tyler" [Second revision?] 36 3 "Eggan" [Revised by Fred Eggan] 36 4 "Minge" [Revised by Ward Allan Minge] 36 5 Unspecified Revised Draft 36 6-7 Unspecified Drafts 36 8 "Most Recent, Edited Copy" 36 9 Footnotes to Findings, Draft 36 10 Miscellaneous papers and Correspondence, Zuni I 37 Staff Documents 37 1

Table of contents from "The Boundaries of Zuni Land," by E. Richard Hart. 3 pages. Includes schedule of maps.

"Position of Earl H. Elam, Ph.D.," 30 pages.

"Comment's on Elam's Report," by T. J. Ferguson. 5 pages. 28 January 1981.

"Zuni claims case: staff conference, January 30-31, 1981," 6 pages.

"Elements of prima facie case," 8 pages.

"Plaintiff's Motion for an Order Excluding Dr. Worcester's Written Report and Prohibiting Dr. Worcester from Testifying at Trial . . .," 1 April 1981.

"Pueblo Indians-Zuni Indians," 2 pages. Brief chronology of events impacting the Pueblos in general and the Zunis in particular, 1853-1892.

 Miscellaneous Correspondence 37 2

Robert E. Lewis to Stephen G. Boyden, 6 June 1980.

Stephen G. Boyden to Floyd A. O'Neil, 13 October 1980.

Richard Hart to Katherine [Kathryn L. MacKay], 20 October 1980.

Richard Hart to Katherine [Kathryn L. MacKay], 8 November 1980.

Richard Hart to Katherine [Kathryn L. MacKay], 23 November 1980.

Ellen Elchlepp to Catherin McKay [Kathryn L. MacKay], 2 December 1980.

Richard Hart to Kathryn L. MacKay, 12 December 1980.

T. J. Ferguson to Allan Aimsworth, 16 December 1980.

Kathryn L. MacKay to Triloki Nath Pandey, 23 December 1980.

Kathryn L. MacKay to Myra Ellen Jenkins, 23 December 1980.

Kathryn L. MacKay to Ward Allan Minge, 23 December 1980.

Kathryn L. MacKay to T. J. Ferguson, 23 December 1980.

E. Richard Hart to Stephen G. Boyden, 9 March 1981.

T. J. Ferguson to Katherine McKay [Kathryn L. MacKay], 9 May 1981.

T. J. Ferguson to Stephen G. Boyden, 22 October 1981.

T. J. Ferguson to Kathryn L. MacKay, 4 December 1981.

 Correspondence of Fred Eggan 37 3

Fred Eggan to Stephen Boyden. 5 pages, includes possible queries in regard to his report.

Corrections and additions to "Aboriginal Land Use of the Zuni Indian Tribe," by Fred Eggan. 3 handwritten pages.

 "Minge: Translations of his Ciations" 37 4 Opinion in Wichita Indian Tribe v. The United States of America 37 5 Relating to Navajo claims cases 37 6

Excerpts from trial transcripts, pages 7169-7288. 16 October 1961.

Excerpts from trial transcripts, pages 7291-7429.

Excerpts from Findings of Fact, The Navajo Tribe of Indians v. The United States of America, pages 256-261. Case decided 29 June 1970.

Excerpt from Jenkins, Myra Ellen, and Minge, Ward Allan, "Navajo Activities Affecting the Acoma-Laguna Area, 1746-1910," in Navajo Indians II (New York: Garland Publishing Inc., 1974).

 Missing Exhibit Lists 37 7

"Missing Exhibits," 22 pages, 20 May 1981.

"Missing Exhibits," 2 pages, n. d.

Substitute Exhibits, 1 page.

"Missing for July 1, 1980," 1 page.

 Text, exhibit citation and footnote corrections 37 8

Text corrections, 6 pages.

Rebuttal text corrections, 3 pages.

Exhibit citation corrections, 10 pages.

Rebuttal exhibit citations, 4 pages.

"Fred Eggan: New and Revised Footnotes," 5 pages.

Footnote citation corrections, 10 pages.

Footnote numbers corrections, 3 pages.

 Exhibit Lists and Errata 37 9

O exhibits, 6 pages.

S exhibit citations, 6 pages.

Additional exhibits, 7 pages.

Errata, 5 pages

 Aberle, S. D. The Pueblo Indians of New Mexico: Their Land, Economy and Civil Organization (American Anthropological Association) 1948 37 10 "Zunis," Excerpt from Unidentified Report 37 11 "Zuni Salt Lake: Text and References" 37 12 E. Richard Hart's "The Boundaries of Zuni Land," and Schedule 37 13 Miscellaneous notes 37 14 Materials Regarding Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses 38 Expert Witnesses, General File 38 1 Questions For Expert Witnesses 38 2 Fred Eggan, Agreement and Correspondence 38 3 Fred Eggan, Draft Rebuttal Report 38 4 T. J. Ferguson, Agreement and Correspondence 38 5 T. J. Ferguson, Rebuttal Materials 38 6 E. Richard Hart, Agreement and Correspondence 38 7 E. Richard Hart, papers and Reports 38 8 E. Richard Hart, Zuni Bibliography 38 9 E. Richard Hart, Rebuttal Materials 38 10 Materials Regarding Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses 39 Myra Ellen Jenkins, Agreement and Correspondence 39 1 Myra Ellen Jenkins, Insert Pages 39 2 Myra Ellen Jenkins, Draft Rebuttal Report 39 3 Ward Allan Minge, Agreement and Correspondence 39 4 Ward Allan Minge, Draft Rebuttal Report 39 5 Triloki N. Pandey, Vita and Agreement 39 6 Triloki N. Pandey, Correspondence 39 7 Triloki N. Pandey, Reports and Publications 39 8 Triloki N. Pandey, Draft Rebuttal Report 39 9 S. Lyman Tyler, Vita, Report and Notes 39 10 Appraisal Report and "E" Documents Relating to Elevation, Topography and Land Use 40 "Appraisal of Zuni Land Claim in Connection with Docket 161-79L." Prepared by Flavell, Tennenbaum & Associates, North Hollywood, California 1991 40 1 E1, "General Ecosystem Survey of the Southwestern Region," USFS 1987 40 1 E2, "Arizona Vegetation Resource Inventory," USGS 1991 40 2 E3, "A Guide to Land Cover Types of Arizona 40 3 E4, "Report of the Commissioner of Immigration for Colfax County, New Mexico" 1880 40 4 E5, "Taos County, Report to the Bureau of Immigration of New Mexico" 1881 40 5 E6, "Patterns of Land Use Within a Portion of the Pueblo of Zuni Land Claim Area" 1988 40 6 E7, "Aboriginal Agricultural Development in the Valley of Sonora, Mexico," The Geographical Review 1980 40 7 E8, "Pre-Hispanic Occupance in the Valley of Sonora, Mexico: Archaeological Confirmation of Early Spanish Reports" 1988 40 8 E9, Mapping the Transmississippi West 1963 40 9 E10, "Land Resource Regions and Major Land Resource Areas of the United States," USDA 1981 40 10 E11, "Soil Survey of Apache County, Arizona," USDA 1975 40 11 E12, "Report and Interpretations for the General Soil Map of Gila County, Arizona," USDA 1974 40 12 E13-14, "General Soil Map of Navajo County, Arizona," USDA 1969-1970 40 13-14 "Seeding New Mexico Rangeland," New Mexico State University 40 15

No exhibit number

 "F" Documents Relating to Farming and Ranching 41

F3-4 and F14 are missing or unused

 F1, "Report on Cattle, Sheep, and Swine" 1880 41 1 F2, 1 page excerpt from unspecified report in reference to dry-farming in Montezuma County, Colorado. 41 2 F5, Murrah, "Success and Failure: Entrepreneurship on the Southern Plains, 1876-1892" 1973 41 3 F6, Sheffy, The Franklyn Land & Cattle Company. 41 4 F7, Pearce, The Matador Land and Cattle Company, chapter 1. 41 5 F8, Murrah, "A Cattle Kingdom on Texas' Last Frontier," M.A. Thesis 1970 41 6 F9, Murrah, The Pitchfork Land and Cattle Company, introduction and chapter 1. 41 7 F10, Murrah, "C. C. Slaughter: The Cattle King of Texas," Ph.D. Dissertation 1979 41 8 F11, Murrah, "C. C. Slaughter: The Cattle King of Texas" 41 9 F12, Holden, The Espuela Land and Cattle Company, chapters 6 and 22. 41 10 F13, Burton, A History of the J A Ranch 1928 41 11 F15, The Capitol Land Reservation in the Panhandle of Texas, pp. 2-22. 41 12 F16, Haley, The XIT Ranch of Texas 1929 41 13 F17, Endnotes and Bibliography to Unspecified Paper 41 14 F18, Murrah, "The Texas Capitol and the XIT: Whatever Happened to All That Land?" 1986 41 15 F19, The Kentucky Cattle Raising Company, p. 11 41 16 F20, Dolman, "The Public Lands of Western Texas, 1870-1900: The Conflict of Public and Private Interests," Ph.D. Dissertation 1974 41 17 F21, Dolman, "The Public Lands of Texas" 41 18 F22, Minute book of the Pitchfork Land and Cattle Company 1883- 1916 41 19 F23, Clary, "Range Management and its Ecological Basis in the Ponderosa Pine Type of Arizona," USDA 1975 41 20 F24, Clary, Kruse and Larson, "Cattle Grazing and Wood Production with Different Basal Areas of Ponderosa Pine," Journal of Range Management 1975 41 21 "G" Documents General and Miscellaneous Documents 42

G5, 23, 26, 33, and 34 are missing or unused.

 G1, Stauber, "Method for Researching U. S. Government Surveys for Zuni Trust Land Damages Claim" 1985 42 1 G2, "Complete List of U. S. General Land Office Survey Maps and Filed Notes Researched for the Zuni II Land Damages Claim" 1985 42 2 G3, Hart, "Townsite Size in the Zuni Claim Area" 1989 42 3 G4, Hickey, "170 Townsites of the Zuni Claim Area" 1989 42 4 G6, New Mexico Statehood Hearings 1910 42 5 G7, Baxter, "Material on Zuni Appraisal Submitted to R. Howard Sears" 1989 42 6 G8, "Earliest U. S. General Land Office Survey Plats of the New Mexico Townships in the Zuni Claim Area" 1990 42 7 G9, Frazer, Forts and Supplies 42 8 G10, Culin, "Report on a Collecting Expedition among the Indians of New Mexico and Arizona" 1903 42 9 G11, Abruzzi, "Ecology, Resource Redistribution, and Mormon Settlement in Northeastern Arizona," American Anthropologist 1989 42 10 G12, Telling, "Ramah, New Mexico" 1876-1900 42 11 G13, Cooper, "Changes in vegetation, Structure, and Growth of Southwestern Pine Forests Since White Settlement," Ecological Monographs 1960 42 12 G14, "The Dynamic West: A Region in Transition" 1989 42 13 G15, "Inventing the West" 1982 42 14 G16, Beck and Hasse, Historical Atlas of New Mexico 42 15 G17, Third Annual Report of the United States Geological Survey 1883 42 16 G18, Dutton, "Mount Taylor and the Zuni Plateau" 1886 42 17 G19, Newspaper citations 42 18 G20, Assessment book for Bernalillo County, New Mexico 1881 42 19 G21, Assessment book for Bernalillo County 1870 42 20 G22, Record Book of the Board of Commissioners of Public Buildings 1853-1857 42 21 G24, Superintendent, Navajo Agency to Commissioner of Indian Affairs 1911 42 22 G25, John Collier to George A. Trotter 1934 42 23 G27, Davis, "Principles and Practices of Condemnation Appraisal," The Appraisal Journal 1950 24 G28, Schmutz, "Appraising for Condemnation," The Appraisal Journal 1952 42 25 G29, McPherson, "The Hindsight Rule," The Appraisal Journal 1953 42 26 G30, Laronge, "The Technique of Preparing for Court Testimony" 1935 42 27 G31, Levit, "The Expert Witness," The Appraisal Journal 1939 42 28 G32, Bowes, "Appraisal of Four Million Acres of Western Land," The Appraisal Journal 1948 42 29 "GM" Documents [General and Miscellaneous Maps] and Census Data 1870-1900 43

GM4, 5, 6, and 9 are missing or unused.

 GM1, "Looking for an Old Map, Out of Print Maps," National Mapping Program, USGS 43 1 GM2, Pepper Canyon, Arizona. USGS Topographic 43 2 GM3, "Publications of the New Mexico Geological Society" 1988 43 3 GM7, Apache-Sitgreaves National Forests, USFS 43 4 GM8, Cibola National Forest, USFS 43 5 GM10, Gila National Forest, USFS 43 6 GM11, Arizona [with precipitation overlay, 1940-1980], High Country Mapping 1985 43 7 GM12, Myra Ellen Jenkins and Albert H. Schroeder, A Brief History of New Mexico 43 8 Jeff Hickey to Jeff Cohen 1990 43 9

Letter concerns the following census data.

 Data from the 9th Census 1870 43 10 Data from the 10th Census 1880 43 11 Data from the 11th Census 1890 43 12 Data from the 12th Census 1900 43 13 "I" Documents Relating to Irrigation and Water Rights 44 I1, "A Historical Study of Non-Federal Water Claims in the Little Colorado River Basin, Arizona," Central States Development 1986 44 1 I2, David Rhode, "Agriculture and Water Use Before the Twentieth Century on the Zuni Reservation, West-Central New Mexico" 1989 44 2 I3, Samuel C. Monson, "Meanings of Arroyo" 44 3 I4, H. Hartmann, "New Mexico Lands" 44 4 I5, "Changes in Geomorphology, Hydrology, and Land Use on the Zuni Indian Reservation, McKinley and Cibola Counties, New Mexico, 1846-1985," Geoscience Consultants, Ltd. 1985 44 5 I6, David Rhode, "Agriculture and Water Use Before the Twentieth Century on the Zuni Reservation, West-Central New Mexico," Entire Report 1989 44 6 I7, "Water Resources of the Zuni Tribal Lands, McKinley and Cibola Counties, New Mexico," USGS Water Supply Paper 2227 44 7 I8, "Suitability of New Mexico Lands for Irrigation," New Mexico State University, Agricultural Experiment Station, Research Report 276 44 8 "L" Legal Documents 45 L1-L3, "Valuation" 45 1-3 L4, Michael J. Kaplan, "Annotation: Proof and Extinguishment of Aboriginal Title to Indian Lands," Lawyers Co-operative Publishing Co. 1988 45 4 L5, Sioux Nation v. United States, Indian Claims Commission Docket 74-B 1974 45 5 L6, Bois Forte Band, et al., v. The United States of America, Indian Claims Commission Docket 18-D 1974 45 6 L7, The Pottawatomie Tribe of Indians, et. al. v. The United States of America, Indian Claims Commission Dockets 15-E, 29-C, 120, 130, 252, and 338 1978 45 7 L8-L9, Indian Claims Commission Awards (Grouped by Fiscal Year) 45 8-9 L10, "ICC Sort, Alphabetical" 45 10 L11, The Fort Sill Apache Tribe of the State of Oklahoma . . . v. The United States of America, Indian Claims Commission Dockets 30-A and 48-A 45 11 L12, Gila River Pima-Maricopa Indian Community, et. al. v. The United States, United States Claims Court Docket 228 1982 45 12 L13, The Jicarilla Apache Tribe of the Jicarilla Apache Reservation, New Mexico, v. The United States of America, Indian Claims Commission Docket 22-A 1970 45 13 L14, Western Shoshone Identifiable Group, Represented by the Temoak Bands of Western Shoshone Indians, Nevada, v. The United States of America, Indian Claims Commission Docket 326-K 1972 45 14 L15, The Northern Paiute Nation v. The United States of America, Indian Claims Commission Docket 87 1965 45 15 L16, The United States v. The Northern Paiute Nation, et. al., United States Court of Claims, 393 F.2d 786; 183 Ct. Cl. 321 1968 45 16 L17, The Tlingit and Haida Indians of Alaska and Harry Douglas, et. al., v. The United States of America, United States Court of Claims, 389 F.2d 778; 182 Ct. Cl. 130 1968 45 17 L18, The Zuni Tribe of New Mexico v. The United States of America, United States Court of Claims Docket 161-79L, "Opinion: Indian Claims; Events and Dates of Taking of Aboriginal Land" 1987 45 18 L19, The Zuni Tribe of New Mexico v. The United States of America, United States Court of Claims Docket 161-79L, "Opinion: Indian Claims; Extent of Aboriginal Land and Title; Exclusive Use and Occupancy" 1987 45 19 "LM" and "MM" Documents Land Use and Mineral Maps 46 LM1, "Land Use and Land Cover and Associated Maps," USGS 46 1 LM2, "Land Use and Land Cover, 1976: Gallup, New Mexico; Arizona," USGS 1980 46 2 LM3, "Preferred Alternative," Coconino National Forest 1986 46 3 LM4, "Off-Road Driving Management Plan," Coconino National Forest 1986 46 4 LM5, "Off-Road Vehicle (ORV) Management Map," Gila National Forest 1986 46 5 LM6, "Transportation System and Utilities Corridors," Gila National Forest 1986 46 6 LM7, "Forest Management Areas," Gila National Forest 1986 46 7 LM8, "Forest Plan," Cibola National Forest 1985 46 8 LM9, "Transportation and Utilities Corridors," Cibola National Forest 1985 46 9 LM10, "Alternatives A thru F," Cibola National Forest 1985 46 10 LM11, "Off-Road Vehicle (ORV) Map," Cibola National Forest 1985 46 11 MM1, "Index of Published Geologic Maps of Arizona, 1903 to 1982," Arizona Bureau of Geology and Mineral Technology 1982 46 12 MM2, "Publications Available," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 1988 46 13 MM3, "Map of Known Metallic Mineral Occurrences (Excluding Base and Precious Metals) in Arizona," Arizona Bureau of Mines 1969 46 14 MM4, "Map of Known Nonmetallic Mineral Occurrences of Arizona," Arizona Bureau of Geology and Mineral Technology 1965 46 15 MM5, "New Mexico Non-Metal Resources Map," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 46 16 MM6, "New Mexico Metal Resources Map," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 46 17 MM7, "Geologic Map Index of Arizona," USGS 1975 46 18 MM8, "Geologic Map Index of New Mexico," USGS 1979 46 19 MM9, "Map of Part of the Workings at the Coal Mine Three Miles West of Pescado," Geoscience Consultants, Ltd 46 20 MM10, "Preliminary Geologic Map of Western San Juan Basin, San Juan and McKinley Counties, New Mexico" 46 21 MM11, "Mines, Processing Plants, and Power Plants in New Mexico," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 1979 46 22 MM12, "Reported Occurrences of Selected Minerals in Arizona" 1969 46 23 MM13, "Reported Occurrences of Selected Minerals in New Mexico" 1965 46 24 MM14, "New Mexico Highway Geologic Map," New Mexico Geological Society 46 25 MM15, "List of Publications," Arizona Geological Society 1987 46 26 MM16, "Open-file List 3," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 1984 46 27 "M" Documents Relating to Mining, 1-46 47 M1, Ernest Oberbillig, "Appraisal of Mineral Property" 47 1 M2, "Strippable Low-Sulphur Coal Resources of the San Juan Basin in New Mexico and Colorado," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 1971 47 2 M3, Anthony J. Rinaldi, "A Review of Hoskold and the Valuation of Mineral Property," The Appraisal Journal 1981 47 3 M4, Donald W. Gentry, "Valuation of Mines and Mineral-Bearing Lands," ASA Valuation 1981 47 4 M5, Noel A. Cleland, "The Valuation of Mineral Rights," AIM 1981 47 5 M6, W. D. Davis, "The Appraisal of Mineral Interests on Farm Properties," Journal of the American Society of Farm Managers and Rural Appraisers 1981 47 6 M7, Susan Pearlman, "Selected Bibliography" 1988 47 7 M8, E. Richard Hart, "Zuni Mining" 1984 47 8 M9, John O. Baxter, "A Summary of Events Concerning Discovery of the Gallup Coal Field" 1989 47 9 M10, Nick Coppin to Richard Hart 1989 47 10 M11, Julian D. Sears, Geology and Coal Resources of the Gallup-Zuni Basin, New Mexico, USGS 1925 47 11 M12, Julian D. Sears, Geology and Fuel Resources of the Southern Part of the San Juan Basin, New Mexico, USGS 1934 47 12 M13, O. E. Kiessling, Statistical Appendix to Minerals Yearboo, 1932-33, U. S. Bureau of Mines 1934 1934 47 13 M14, Lindgren, Graton and Gordon, The Ore Deposits of New Mexico, USGS 1910 47 14 M15, Fayette Alexander Jones, New Mexico Mines and Minerals 1904 47 15 M18, J. R. Finlay, "Report of Appraisal of Mining Properties of New Mexico," New Mexico State tax Commission 1921-1922 47 16 M19, Eugene Carter Anderson, "The Metal resources of New Mexico and Their Economic Features Through 1954," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 1957 47 17 M20, Samuel G. Lasky and Thomas P. Wootton, "The Metal Resources of New Mexico and Their Economic Features," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 1933 47 18 M21, "Mineral and Water Resources of New Mexico," New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources 1965 47 19 M22, Report of the Governor of New Mexico to the Secretary of the Interior 1892 47 20 M23, John C. Spears, "Report of the Territorial Inspector of Coal Mines to the Governor of the Territory of New Mexico" 1893 47 21 M24-29, Reports of the Governors of New Mexico 1893-1901 47 22 M31, Contributions to Economic Geology 1907, USGS 1909 47 23 M32, Charts and tables from the Bulletins of the New Mexico Bureau of Mines 47 24 M33, Jerry L. Williams, New Mexico in Maps 47 25 M34, Chart of Coal Production in New Mexico 47 26 M35, "New Mexico," and "Arizona," in Mines and Mining West of the Rocky Mountains 47 27 M36, F. C. Schrader, "The Durango-Gallup Coal Field of Colorado and New Mexico," Contributions to Economic Geology 1905 47 28 M37, James MacFarlane, The Coal-Regions of America: Their Topography, Geology, and Development 1875 47 29 M38, Millard K. Shaler, "A Reconnaissance Survey of the Western Part of the Durango-Gallup Coal Field of Colorado and New Mexico," Contributions to Economic Geology 1906 1907 47 30 M40, J. B. Tenney, The Mineral Industries of Arizona 1928 47 31 M41, Jules Marcou, Geology of North America, Zurich 1858 47 32 M42, Albert Williams, Mineral Resources of the United States, USGS 1885 47 33 M43, David T. Day, Mineral Resources of the United States, USGS 1890 47 34 M44, "Report of the United States Coal Mine Inspector for the Territory of New Mexico" 1895 47 35 M45, Rossiter W. Raymond, "Statistics of Mines and Mining in the States and Territories" 1870 47 36 M46, "Geological Survey of the Territories," Sixth Annual Report of the United States Geological Survey 1873 47 37 "M" Documents [Relating to Mining], 47-60 48 M47, "Report upon Geographical and Geological Explorations and Surveys West of the One Hundredth Meridian, in Charge of First Lieut. Geo. M. Wheeler," Engineer Department, U. S. Army 1875 48 1 M48, The Resources of Arizona 1881 48 2 M49, Patrick Hamilton, The Resources of Arizona 1884 48 3 M50, Stuart A. Northrop, Minerals of New Mexico. Book 1959 48 4 M51, "Metallic Mineral Districts and Production in Arizona," Arizona Bureau of Geology and Mineral Technology 1983 48 5 M52, "Mine Index for Metallic Mineral Districts of Arizona," Arizona Bureau of Geology and Mineral Technology 1985 48 6 M53, Director, USGS, to Secretary of the Interior 1899 48 7 M54, Placer Mining Act of July 9, 1870, 16 Stat 217 July 9, 1870 48 8 M55, Act to Promote the Development of the Mining Resources of the United States, 17 Stat 91 1872 48 9 M56, Clement J. Schwingle, "Natural Resources," The Bibliography of Appraisal Literature 48 10 M57, Philip W. Grossman, "The Valuation of Land with Underlying Natural Resources," The Journal of the American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers 48 11 M58, "Mineral Rights-Coal Lands," 1 page 48 12 M59, "Report upon United States Geographical Surveys West of the One Hundredth Meridian, in Charge of Capt. Geo. M. Wheeler," Engineer Department, U.S. Army 1889 48 13 M60, "Report upon the Geographical and Geological Explorations and Surveys West of the One Hundredth Meridian, in Charge of First Lieut. Geo. M. Wheeler," Engineer Department, U. S. Army 1875 48 14 "P" Relating to Public Lands and "R" Relating to Railroads Documents 49

P6 is missing or unused.

 P1, Jeff Hickey, "The Minimum Value of Public Lands" 49 1 P2, Jeff Hickey to Robert H. Flavelle 6 October 1989 49 2

Includes data on price of public lands.

 P3, Victor Westphall, The Public Domain in New Mexico 1854-1891 1965 49 3 P4, "Private Land Grants in Arizona," U. S. House of Representatives, Report 172 1883-1884 49 4 P5, "Right of Way Through Public Lands of the United States in the Territory of Utah," U. S. House of Representatives, Report 3973 1887 49 5 P7, Congressional Record 1874 49 6 P8, An Act Making Further Provision for the Sale of Public Lands, 3 Stat 566 1820 49 7 P9, "Public Lands of Arizona" 49 8 P10, Single sheet stating "this is a book," but no book could be found 49 9 P11, An Act to Authorize the Entry of Lands Chiefly Valuable for Building Stone under the Placer Mining Laws, 27 Stat 348 1892 49 10 P12, H. R. Stucky and Donald C. Henderson, "Grazing Capacities and Selected Factors Affecting Public Land Use," New Mexico State University Agricultural Experiment Station Research Report 158 1969 49 11 R1, Vernon J. Glover and Joseph P. Hereford, Jr., "Cultural Resources Management: Zuni Mountain Railroads, Cibola National Forest, New Mexico," USFS 1986 49 12 R2, "Forfeiture of Certain Public Lands Granted as a Railroad Right of Way, etc.," Hearings before the House Judicial Committee 1916 49 13 R3, L. L. Waters, Steel Trails to Santa Fe 1950 49 14 R4, Irving Telling, "New Mexico Frontiers: A Social History of the Gallup Area, 1881-1901," Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard University 1952 49 15 R5, "Letter from the Secretary of the Interior" 1872 49 16 R6, "Letter from the Secretary of the Interior" 1879 49 17 R7, "Letter of the Secretary of the Interior" 1884 49 18 R8, "Letter of the Secretary of the Interior" 1886 49 19 R9, William J. Palmer, Report of Surveys Across the Continent 1868 49 20 R11, "Physical Valuation of Railroad PropertieR10, "Letter of the Secretary of War" 1879 49 21 R11, "Physical Valuation of Railroad Properties," Hearing before the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce of the House of Representatives 1911 49 22 R12, "Extension of Time for Completion of the Alaska Northern Railroad," Hearings before the Committee on the Territories, House of Representatives 1913 49 23 R13, "Memorial of the Legislative Assembly of New Mexico" 1864 49 24 R14, "Pacific Railroads," House Miscellaneous Document 132 1876 49 25 R15, "Taxation of Railroad Lands," House Report 474 1874 49 26 R16, Unidentified Report 49 27 R17, Memorials to the U. S. Senate 1880 49 28 R18, Correspondence in regard to railroad Packages 1871-1881 49 29 R19, The Congressional Globe 49 30 R20, J. A. Williamson to N. C. McFarland 1881 49 31 R21, Grant Foreman, A Pathfinder in the Southwest 1941 49 32 R22, Charles H. Wood, "Railroad Land Grants and Land-Grant Rate Deductions" 1939 49 33 Railroad Sales-Small Acre Sales 49 34 "SP" and "TM" Documents [Subject Property and Topographic Maps] 50 SP1-11, Subject Property Maps 50 1 SP12A, "Map of the Zuni Reservation Showing Major Towns, Roads & Drainages" 50 2 SP12B, "Map Showing Location of Incised Stream Channels on Zuni Reservation" 50 3 SP12C, "Map of Dams and Reservoirs on the Zuni Reservation" 1946 50 4 SP12D, "Geologic Map of the Zuni Reservation" 50 5 SP12E, "Map of Established Roads on the Zuni Reservation" Before 1946 50 6 SP12F, "Map of Arable Areas and Lands Under Cultivation" 50 7 SP13, "Zuni Claim Area Land Classification Acreages" 50 8 TM1, New Mexico: Catalog of Topographic and Other Published Maps, USGS 1987 50 9 TM2, New Mexico: Index to Topographic and Other map Coverage, USGS 50 10 "T" Documents [Relating to Timber Resources], 1-30 51 T1, E. Richard Hart, "Lumber and Log Values in New Mexico Prior to 1900" 1989 51 1 T2, T. J. Ferguson, "An Analysis of Timber Values in the Zuni Claim Area" 1989 51 2 T3, Minutes from Directors' Meetings of Unidentified Organization 51 3 T4, "Schedule 4-Products of Industry in New Mexico" 1870 51 4 T5, "Lumber Mills and Saw Mills-Brick Yards and Tile Works," New Mexico 1880 51 5 T6, "Lumber Mills and Saw Mills-Brick Yards and Tile Works," New Mexico 1880 51 6 T7, Susan Pearlman, "Report on Search for Statistics Regarding Pre-Cut Volumes on the Apache, Sitgreaves, Prescott, Gila, and Coconino National Forests" 1988 51 7 T8, Edward Stuart, Jr., "Appraisal of Timber and Timberland" 51 8 T9, W. David Klemperer, "Segregating Land and Timber Values from Sales of Uneven-Aged Forests," The Appraisal Journal 1979 51 9 T10, W. David Klemperer, "Valuing Young Timber Scheduled for Future Harvest," The Appraisal Journal 1987 51 10 T11, W. David Klemperer, "The Effects of Inflation and Debt on Old Growth Timber Appraisal," The Appraisal Journal 1985 51 11 T12, Timothy D. Newman, "Appraisal of Timber: A Direct Sales Approach," The Appraisal Journal 1984 51 12 T13, Charles M. Tarver, "Valuation of Timberland," Appraisal Review Journal 1982 51 13 T14, Charles Freudenberg, "The Timberland Investment-Fact and Fiction," The Appraisal Review 1988 51 14 T15, Gary Allen Burns, "Timber and Timberland Appraisal," ASA Valuation 1983 51 15 T16, G. M. Guthrie to Commissioner of Indian Affairs 1910 51 16 T17, Superintendent, Navajo Agency to Commissioner of Indian Affairs 1911 51 17 T18, Acts relating to the Timberlands of the United States 51 18 T19, Bruce Fox to Jeff Cohen, 9 November 1989. Includes, Walter H. Meyer, "Yield of Even-Aged Stands of Ponderosa Pine," USDA 1938 51 19 T20, "Rehabilitation Plan for the Community of Page, New Mexico" 51 20 T21, E. Richard Hart, "The Zuni National Forest Lands" 1909-1924 51 21 T22, John Ise, The United States Forest Policy 1920 51 22 T23, Cox, Thomas, Maxwell and Malone, This Well-Wooded Land: Americans and Their Forests from Colonial Times to the Present 1985 51 23 T24, Henry Clepper, Professional Forestry in the United States 1971 51 24 T25, Richard M. Alston, The Individual v. The Public Interest: Political Ideology and National Forest Policy 1983 51 25 T26, Robert L. Matheny, "Lumbering in the White Mountains of Arizona," Arizona and the West 1976 51 26 T27, History of Arizona Territory 51 27 T28, "Coconino National Forest Plan," USFS 1987 51 28 T29, Baker, Maxwell, Treat and Dethloff, Timeless Heritage: A History of the Forest Service in the Southwest, USFS 1988 51 29 T30, Dwane D. Van Hooser, "Timberland and Woodland Resources Outside National Forests in Northwestern New Mexico, 1987," USFS 1987 51 30 "T" Documents Relating to Timber Resources, 31-36 52 T31, "Summary of the Environmental Impact Statement for the Gila National Forest Plan," USFS 1986 52 1 T32, "Gila National Forest Plan," USFS 1986 52 2 T33, "Environmental Impact Statement, Gila National Forest Plan," USFS 1986 52 3 T34, "Cibola National Forest Land and Resource Management Plan," USFS 1985 52 4 T35, "Summary of Environmental Impact Statement for the Cibola National Forest Plan," USFS 1985 52 5 T36, "Environmental Impact Statement for the Cibola National Forest Plan," USFS 1985 52 6 "T" Documents [Relating to Timber Resources], 37; and Data on Timber Cut and Sold 1909-1940 53 "T" Documents [Relating to Timber Resources], 38-49 54 T38, Susan Pearlman, "Timber Valuations-District 3 (Region 3) Timber Cut" 1988 54 1 T39, Wilford Woodruff: History of His Life and Labors as Recorded in His Daily Journals 1909 54 2 T40, David A. Clary, Timber and the Forest Service 1986 54 3 T41, J. P. Kinney, Indian Forest and Range: A History of the Administration and Conservation of the Redman's Heritage 1950 54 4 T42, Gilbert M. Schubert, "Silvaculture of Southwestern Ponderosa Pine: The Status of Our Knowledge," USFS 1974 54 5 T43, Charles F. Cooper, "Changes in Vegetation, Structure and Growth of Southwestern Pine Forests Since White Settlement," Ecological Monographs 1960 54 6 T44, "Crystal Forest Museum & Gift Shop" 54 7 T45, Edwin A. Tucker and george Fitzpatrick, Men Who Matched the Mountains: The Forest Service in the Southwest 1972 54 8 T46, Forest Service Atlas 1908 54 9 T47, "Secretary's Contract No. 17818: Santa Fe Pacific Railroad Company, with Arizona Lumber and Timber Company, Dated October 11, 1898; Effective January 1, 1899" January 1, 1899 54 10 T48, "Timber References at SEC" 54 11 T49, Alfred A. Wiener, "The Forest Service Timber Appraisal System: A Historical Perspective, 1891-1981" 1982 54 12 "V" Documents Relating to Valuation, 1-15 55 V1, Bronson Cutting to John Collier 1934 55 1 V2, Charles H. Burke to Robert J. Bauman 1922 55 2 V3, "Zuni I Area Calculations Data Dictionary" 1987 55 3 V4, E. Richard Hart, "Boundaries of Zuni Land" 55 4 V5, Susan Pearlman, "Property Values from Zuni I and II Testimony" 1988 55 5 V6, William S. Greever, Arid Domain: The Santa Fe Railway and its Western Land Grant 55 6 V7, "Message from the President of the United States," House Executive Document 221 1886 55 7 V8, "Letter from the Secretary of the Interior," House Executive Document 11 1884 55 8 V9, "Hearings Before the Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce of the House of Representatives on the Bill H. R. 12811" 55 9 V10, "Letter from the Secretary of the Interior," Senate Executive Document 106 1885 55 10 V11, Assessment Rolls of Washington County 55 11 V12, Assessment Rolls of Weber County 55 12 V13, E. Richard Hart, "Minimum Values in the Zuni Claim Area: An Historical Perspective" 1989 55 13 V14, E. Richard Hart, "Rebuttal Report: 'Damage to Zuni Trust Lands" 1988 55 14 V15, Jeff Hickey, "170 Townsites of the Zuni Claim Area" 1989 55 15 "V" Documents Relating to Valuation, 16-25 56

V16, Volume 1, is missing.

 V16, "Land Sales: Bernalillo County, Sandoval County, New Mexico" Volume 2 1879-1939 56 1 V16, "Land Sales: Santa Fe County, New Mexico" Volume 3 1883-1948 56 2 V16, "An Economic Analysis of Central New Mexico" Volume 4: Source Documents I-X 1879-1979 56 3 V16, Volume 4: Source Documents XI-XXXVI 56 4-5 V 17-25 56 6

V17, Ahmed Kooros and Theodore Reynolds Smith, "The Opportunity Cost Doctrine," The Appraisal Journal 1983.

V18, Fred Singleton, "Appraisal of Indian Reserve Lands," Right of Way 1983.

V19, William V. Lowry, "Indian Lands: A Peculiar Market," The Canadian Appraiser 1987.

V20, Theodore Reynolds Smith and Ahmed Kooros, "Application of the Opportunity of Cost Doctrine to Right-of-Way Valuation," Real Estate Appraiser and Analyst 1984.

V21, William deBuys, "Las Trampas Grant," New Mexico Historical Review 1981.

V22, "Rehabilitation Plan for the Community of Page, New Mexico."

V23, "Ramah, New Mexico," Utah State Historical Society 1953.

V24, Robert J. Bauman to (?) Jones, 2 March 1917.

V25, Capt. John L. Bullis to Commissioner of Indian Affairs, 20 April 1896.

 Other Appraisal Reports, Volumes 1 -7 57 Vol. 1; Don D. Dwyer, "Review of the Report: Appraisal of the Lands of the Navajo Indian Tribe in New Mexico, Arizona, Utah and Colorado by V. A. Englehorn" 57 1 Vol. 2; Vern A. Englehorn, "Appraisal of the Lands of the Navajo Indian Tribe in New Mexico, Arizona, Utah and Colorado" 1977 57 2 Vol. 3; Vern A. Englehorn, "Supplement to Appraisal of the Lands of the Navajo Indian Tribe in New Mexico, Arizona, Utah and Colorado" 1977 57 3 Vol. 4; E. Richard Hart, "The Zuni Mountains: Chronology of an Environmental Disaster" 1988 57 4 Vol. 5 (?); E. Richard Hart, "The Zuni Mountains: Chronology of an Environmental Disaster" 1988 57 5 Vol. 6; Idaho Land and Appraisal Service, "Appraisal of Jicarilla-Apache Reservation v. The United States of America" 57 6 Vol. 7; Idaho Land and Appraisal Service, "Appraisal of Jicarilla Apache Tribe v. United States of America" 57 7 Other Appraisal Reports, Volumes 8-11 58 Vol. 8; Idaho Land and Appraisal Service, "Appraisal of the Lands of the San Carlos Apache Tribe, the White Mountain Apache Tribe, the Western Apache Tribe, the Northern Tonto Apache Tribe in Arizona" 58 1 Vol. 9; Allan L. McMullen, "Valuation of Jicarilla Apache Lands" 58 2 Vol. 10; C. Mark Miller, "Appraisal of Ute Ceded Tract, Colorado, 1873-1874" 1956 58 3 Vol. 11; Ernest Oberbillig, "Mineral Appraisal of the Navajo Tract as of July 25, 1868" 1977 58 4 Other Appraisal Reports, Volumes 12-17 59 Vol. 12; R. Howard Sears, "Appraisal Report of the Acoma Pueblo Land, State of New Mexico, as of 1901-1936" 1970 59 1 Vol. 13; R. Howard Sears, "Preliminary Draft: Appraisal Report of the Zuni Indian Land Territory's [sic] and States of New Mexico and Arizona as of 1846-1939" 1989 59 2 Vol. 14 (?); Zuni I: Land Claim Valuation Data Search 59 3 Vol. 15; Neil A. Thomas and Steven Cassin, "An Appraisal of the Lands of the Navajo Tribe Acquired by the United States under Treaty of June 1, 1868" 1977 59 4 Vol. 16; Neil A. Thomas and Steven Cassin, "Analysis of Government Appraisal" 59 5 Vol. 17; R. Howard Sears, "Index of Reference Material, Maps and Charts in the Appraisal Report of the Laguna Pueblo Land, State of New Mexico, as of 1908-1936" 1970 59 6 Land Appraisal by Market Data Research 60 Market Data Research, "Appraisal Report of the Zuni Land Claim, Territory's [sic] & States of New Mexico and Arizona as of 1846-1939," Volume I December 1990 60 1 Market Data Research, "Appraisal Report of the Zuni Land Claim . . .," Volume II: Surveyor Township Descriptions December 1990 60 2 Miscellaneous maps 61 Zuni I Miscellaneous maps 61 1 The Zuni Tribe of New Mexico v. the United States of America, Docket 327-84L III Report of E. Richard Hart and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiffs Exhibits 1000-1004 62 PX 1000. E. Richard Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands," parts I-II 62 1 PX 1000. Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands," part III 62 2 PX 1000. Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands," appendices 62 3 PX 1001.1-1004 62 4 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1005-1125.2 63 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1126-1245 64 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1246-1370 65 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1371-1435 66 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1436-1524 67 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1525-1663 68 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1664-1771 69 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1772.1-1850 70 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." Plaintiff's Exhibits 1851-1885 71 Report of Geoscience Consultants, Ltd., and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 2000-2022 72 PX 2000. Geoscience Consultants, Ltd. 1985 72 1

"Changes in Geomorphology, Hydrology, and Land Use on the Zuni Indian Reservation, McKinley and Cibola Counties, New Mexico, 1846-1985."

 PX 2000. Geoscience Consultants, Ltd. 1988 72 2

"Rebuttal Report: Geomorphology, Hydrology, and Land Use on the Zuni Indian Reservation, 1846-1988."

 PX 2001-2008 72 3-6 PX 2009-2020. PX 2017 72 7

"Map Atlas: Soil and Range Inventory of the Zuni Indian Reservation," is stored box 73

 PX 2021-2022. 72 8

Photocopies of aerial photographs stored in a separate collection containing PX 2021-2025

 PX 2017. "Map Atlas: Soil and Range Inventory of the Zuni Indian Reservation." Bureau of Indian Affairs 1970 73 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of Geoscience Consultants, Ltd. Plaintiff's Exhibits 2023-2028 74 PX 2023-2025 74 1-3

Photocopies of aerial photographs stored in a separate collection containing PX 2021-2025.

 PX 2026 74 4 PX 2027.1-2028.17 74 5-6

Topographic maps.

 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of Geoscience Consultants, Ltd. Plaintiff's Exhibits 2029-2100 75 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of Geoscience Consultants, Ltd. Plaintiff's Exhibits 2101-2169 76 Reports of Stephen A. Hall and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 3000-3128 77 PX 3000. Stephen A. Hall, "Erosion of Zuni Indian Lands." 1985 77 1 PX 3000. Stephen A. Hall, "Rebuttal Report: Erosion of Zuni Indian Reservation Lands." 1988 77 2 PX 3001-3128 77 3-10 Report of Jeffrey S. Dean and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 4000-4032 78 PX 4000. Jeffrey S. Dean, "Dendro-chronological Dating of Floodplain Erosion on Zuni Indian Lands, Northwestern New Mexico" 78 1 PX 4001-4032 78 2-4 Report of Martin Rose and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 5000-5129 79 PX 5000. Martin Rose, "Present and Past Climate of the Zuni Region." 1985 79 1 PX 5001-5129 79 2-11 Report of T. J. Ferguson and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 6000-6043 80 PX 6000. 80 1

T. J. Ferguson, "Patterns of Land Use and Environmental Change on the Zuni Indian Reservation, 1846-1985: Ethnohistorical and Archaeological Evidence." 30 September 1985

 PX 6000. Maps Accompanying Report Above 7 items 80 2 PX 6000. T. J. Ferguson, "Rebuttal Report: Land Use and Land Damage on the Zuni Indian Reservation, 1846-1888." 31 August 1988 80 3 PX 6001-6043 80 4-9 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of T. J. Ferguson. Plaintiff's Exhibits 6044-6124.2 81 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of T. J. Ferguson. Plaintiff's Exhibits 6125.1-6237.4 82 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of T. J. Ferguson. Plaintiff's Exhibits 6238.1-6266 83 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of T. J. Ferguson. Plaintiff's Exhibits 6267-6321 84 Report of Richard I. Ford and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 7000-7150 85 PX 7000. Richard I. Ford, "Zuni Land Use and Damage to Trust Land." 1985 85 1 PX 7000. Richard I Ford, "Rebuttal Report: Zuni Land Use and Damage to Trust Land." 1988 85 2 PX 7001-7150 85 3-10 Supporting Documentation for the Reports of Richard I. Ford. Plaintiff's Exhibits 7151-7245 86 Photographic Exhibits and Reports. Plaintiff's Exhibits 8000-8075 87 PX 8000. 87 1

T. J. Ferguson and E. Richard Hart, "Rebuttal Report: Interpretation of Historical and Contemporary Photographs." 7 December 1988

 PX 8001-8394. Photographic Exhibits 87 2 PX 8234-8287, 8328-8356. Photographic Exhibits Vol. 4 87 3 PX 8001-8075. Photographs 87 4-8 Photographic Exhibits. Plaintiff's Exhibits 8076-8265 88 Photographic Exhibits and Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 8266-8440 89 PX 8266-8400. Photographs 89 1-9 PX 8401-8440 89 10-14 Appraisals 89A "Appraisal of Ellsworth Ranch as of August 28, 1984" Located at Hunt, Arizona. Prepared for Superintendent, Pueblo of Zuni Agency Prepared by Harold S. Brice August 28, 1984 89A 1 "Appraisal of Zuni Heaven as of August 28, 1845" Located at Hunt, Arizona. Prepared for Superintendent, Pueblo of Zuni Agency Prepared by Harold S. Brice August 28, 1845 89A 2 Documentation for Photographic Exhibits. Plaintiff's Exhibits 8441-8462 90 Report of John O. Baxter and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 9000-9047 91 PX 9000 1988 91 1

John O. Baxter, "Patterns of Land Use within a Portion of the Pueblo of Zuni Land Claim Area"

 PX 9001-9047 91 2-6 Report of James I. Ebert and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 10,000-10,144 92 PX 10,000 1988 92 1

James I. Ebert, "Historic Photographs: Photointerpretation and Photo-grammetry Using Terrestrial and Aerial Photographs in and Around the Zuni Indian Reservation to Define the Nature and History of Watercourse Erosion and Forest Cutting." Includes photgraphic Exhibits 10,001-10,144.

 PX 10,105-10,144 92 2-3 Report of Samuel C. Monson and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 11,000-11,123 93 PX 11,000 1988 93 1

Samuel C. Monson, "The Changing Meaning of Arroyo."

 PX 11,001-11,123 93 2-8 Report of Andrew Wiget and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 12,000-12,024 94 PX 12,000 94 1

Andrew Wiget, "Review and Discussion of Certain Statements Concerning Oral History Contained in the Testimony of Thomas R. Wessel, Ph.D.: 'Federal Government Activity on the Zuni Reservation,' pp. v-vi.'"

 PX 12,001-12,024 94 2-4 Report of E. Richard Hart and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 13,000-13,117 95 PX 13,000. E. Richard Hart, "The Zuni Mountains: Chronology of an Environmental Disaster." 11 September 1988 95 1 PX 13,001.1-13,117 95 2-9 Supporting Documentation for Hart, "The Zuni Mountains." Plaintiff's Exhibits 13,118.1-13,307.2 96 Reports of Environmental Systems Research Institute, E. Richard Hart and Supporting Documentation. Plaintiff's Exhibits 14,000-15,154.16 97 PX 14,000. Environmental Systems Research Institute, "Zuni Agricultural Fields Pilot Study Data Dictionary." August 1988 97 1 PX 15,000. E. Richard Hart, "Rebuttal Report: Damage to Zuni Trust Lands." 23 November 1988 97 2 PX 15,001-15,154.16 97 3-7 Report of Patricia Nelson Limerick, PX 16,000-16,001, and Statements before the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, United States House of Representatives 98 PX 16,000 1988 98 1

Report of Patricia Nelson Limerick evaluating Thomas R. Wessel's "Federal Government Activity on the Zuni Reservation."

 "Statement of E. Richard Hart, Before the Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, United States House of Representatives," Concerning H.R. 4750: "Zuni Settlement Fund Act of 1988." 1988 98 2 Report of Thomas R. Wessel and Supporting Documentation. Defendant's Exhibits 11,000-11,055 99 DX 11,000. Thomas R. Wessel, "Federal Government Activity on the Zuni Reservation" 99 1 Maps accompanying DX 11,000 99 2

1877 Reservation Boundary.

Lands Added in 1883.

Lands Added in 1917.

Lands Added in 1935 and Other Recent Acquisitions.

Lands Added in 1949.

Zuni Agricultural Area Map.

 DX 11,001-11,055 99 3-10 Supporting Documentation for Wessel, "Federal Government Activity on the Zuni Reservation." Defendant's Exhibits 11,056-11,153 100 Supporting Documentation for Wessel, "Federal Government Activity on the Zuni Reservation." Defendant's Exhibits 11,154-11,253 101 Supporting Documentation for Wessel, "Federal Government Activity on the Zuni Reservation." Defendant's Exhibits 11,254-11,289. Plaintiff's Memos Concerning the Wessel Report 102 DX 11,254-11,289 102 1-4 Response Memos Concerning the Wessel Report from the Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses 102 5 Report of Stephen G. Wells and Supporting Documentation. Defendant's Exhibits 12,000-12,018 103 DX 12,000. 103 1

Stephen G. Wells, "A Quantitative Analysis of Arroyo Development and Geomorphic Processes in the Zuni River Drainage Basin, West-Central New Mexico." Volume 1: Technical Report

 Errata and Maps Accompanying DX 12,000: Volume 1 103 2 DX 12,000. 103 3

Stephen G. Wells, "A Quantitative Analysis of Arroyo Development and Geomorphic Processes in the Zuni River Drainage Basin, West-Central New Mexico." Volume 2: Appendices

 Exhibit list for DX 12,001-12,167 103 4 DX 12,001-12,018 103 5-6 Supporting Documentation for Wells, "A Quantitative Analysis of Arroyo Development . . ." Defendant's Exhibits 12,019-12,143 104 Supporting Documentation for Wells, "A Quantitative Analysis of Arroyo Development . . ." Defendant's Exhibits 12,144-12,167. Plaintiff's Memos Concerning the Wells Report 105 DX 12,144-12,167 105 1-5 Response Memos Concerning the Wells Report from the Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses 105 6 Report of Resource Consultants, Inc. and Supporting Documentation. Defendant's Exhibits 13,000-13,052. Plaintiff's Memos Concerning DX 13,000 106 DX 13,000. 106 1

Resource Consultants, Inc., "Analysis of Changes in Hydrology, Hydraulics, and Sediment Transport, Zuni Indian Reservation, New Mexico"

 DX 13,001-13,052 106 2-8 Response Memos Concerning the Resource Consultants Report from the Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses 106 9 Report of Gordon C. Jacoby and Supporting Documentation. Defendant's Exhibits 14,000-14,011 107 DX 14,000 107 1

Gordon C. Jacoby, "Dendro-chronological Investigation of the Zuni Indian Reservation"

 DX 14,001-14,011 107 2-3 Report of Robert C. Balling and Supporting Documentation. Defendant's Exhibits 15,000-15,025. Plaintiff's Memos Concerning DX 15,000 108 DX 15,000 108 1

Robert C. Balling, Jr., "Analysis of Zuni Indian Reservation Precipitation Patterns During the Period of Instrumental Record"

 DX 15,001-15,025 108 2-7 Response Memos Concerning Balling Report from Plaintiff's Expert Witnesses 108 8 Report of Thadis W. Box and Supporting Documentation. DX 16,000-16,037. Plaintiff's Memos Concerning DX 16,000 109 DX 16,000. 109 1

Thadis W. Box, "Range Management on the Zuni Reservation, 1846-1946"

 DX 16,001-16,037 109 2-10 Response memo Concerning Box Report from Plaintiff's Expert Witness T. J. Ferguson 109 11 Report of Loren D. Potter and Supporting Documentation. Defendant's Exhibits 17,000-17,024 110 DX 17,000. 110 1

Loren D. Potter, "Letter Reports: Ecological Interpretations of the Zuni Indian Reservation, New Mexico"

 Loren D. Potter, "Exhibits and Bibliography" 110 2 DX 17,001-17,024 110 3-5 PX 15,154.12-15,154.13, and Miscellaneous Maps

Docket 327-81L

 The United States of America v. Platt IV Reports of E. Richard Hart in regard to the case of The United States v. Platt 111 E. Richard Hart, "The Trail to Kolhu/wala:wa," Draft Conclusions 1986 111 1 E. Richard Hart, "'The Barefoot Trail:' Access to 'Zuni Heaven'" 1986 111 2 E. Richard Hart, "'The Barefoot Trail,' Appendix I: Photographs of Sites Located Along We:sakyaya Onnane" 111 3 Miscellaneous materials: general Zuni claims V Miscellaneous Historical Sources and Reports 112 Statutes regarding American Indian lands and claims 112 1 Bureau of Indian Affairs correspondence 112 2 Miscellaneous historical sources 112 3 Historical articles and book reviews 112 4 Frank Hamilton Cushing, "Zuni Breadstuff," Indian Notes and Monographs 1974 112 5

Reprint ed., New York: The Heye Foundation

 William B. Taylor, "Cochití Lands and the Disputed Sale to Luis María Cabeza de Baca 1805 112 6 T. J. Ferguson and E. Richard Hart, A Zuni Atlas 1985 112 1

Norman: University of Oklahoma Press

 Miscellaneous Reports and Drafts by E. Richard Hart Regarding Zuni History and Claims 113 "The Zuni Land Claim: The Loss of a Legal Right" 113 1 "Through Your Body Perish: A Biography of Pedro Pino (Lai-iu-tsai-lu), Governor of Zuni Pueblo 1830-1878" 1979 113 2 "Zuni Agriculture: An Historical Application of Ethnological Research" 1980 113 3 Untitled Zuni Manuscript 113 4 Miscellaneous Short Reports 113 5

"Zuni Land," "Cushing and the Pinos," and "The Logan Case."

 Addendum VI Zuni I 114 Zuni I 115 Zuni I 116 Zuni I 117 Zuni I 118 Zuni I 119 Zuni II 120 Zuni II 121 Zuni II 122 Zuni II 123 Zuni II 124 Zuni II 125 Zuni II 126 Zuni II 127 Zuni General 128 Zuni General 129 Zuni Water 130 Zuni Water 131 Zuni Water 132 Zuni Heaven 133 Zuni Heaven 134 Zuni Claims 135 Zuni Claims 136 Zuni Claims 137 White River Shale Project 138 Zuni Tribal Code 139 Zuni Petitions 140 Financial records 141 Financial records 142 Financial records 143 Zuni Law 144 Research on the Zuni 145 Research on the Zuni 146 Research on the Zuni 147 Research on the Zuni 148 Research on the Zuni 149 Empty Pre-Labeled Folders 150